The Influence of Gregory of Nazianzus

With skilled help, then, Gregory completed the dossier of Orations he had been working on for several months. These would represent his full doctrinal exposition, and were intended to be given in close succession to each other, and as the context sometimes indicates, probably allowed for subsequent debate. There were certainly Eunomian (Anhomoian) theologians, as well as Homoian clergy of Demophilos in attendance at these orations, and Gregory knew that he was expected to give the performance of his life. In the subsequent history of the ancient Church, these five Orations were never surpassed for their trinitarian doctrine and were, in fact, adopted as the ultimate statement of Trinitarian orthodoxy despite what the conciliar creed of 381 had to say. It is a providential irony that the creed, which was itself a clear and explicit rebuke of Gregory’s boldness in teaching the consubstantiality of the Spirit, has come in the subsequent history of theology to be so strictly interpreted in terms of Gregory’s Orations. He may have felt he lost the day when he made his way back to Cappadocia in the latter part of the following year. He could hardly have envisaged the  manner in which his work would become established as the foundations of Christian orthodoxy. He could hardly win an attentive audience on the occasion, so restless were his critics when he preached. For centuries after him, this sheaf of Orations became the chief trinitarian curriculum of all the Eastern schools, and of almost as great importance to the West after Rufinus translated them into Latin.

John McGuckin, Saint Gregory of Nazianzus: An Intellectual Biography (Crestwood: SVS, 2001), 277.

Manuscript Website

I was looking through evagriusponticus.net again at how nicely Joel Kalvesmaki has organized the list of writings and noticed a little link that said “find MSS”. Curiosity overwhelmed me and I discovered a great site that lists Greek manuscripts with other relevant data: Pinakes: Textes et manuscrits grecs (hosted by Institut de recherche et d’histoire des textes). Those who work closely with manuscripts probably know about it already, but for those who don’t (like myself), this is exciting! You can find a list of an authors work (like, say, Gregory of Nazianzus), and select a text (let’s use the First Theological Oration) to find the information you need. The website is in French, so for those who don’t read French (and if you are studying the Early Church I should add “yet”), you may need to utilize translation software.

Of the Buying of Books, There Is No End

Here are my recently acquired books over the holiday season. Now if I just had the time to read them…

Philosophy

Theology/Patristics

Language

Gregory of Nazianzus on the Care of the Poor

Gregory, as Bernard Coulie has effectively demonstrated in a long study devoted to the subject,[1] had spent a long time in his career reflecting on the moral value of wealth. This is hardly surprising when we consider his personal situation as the son of a very wealthy, landowning, bishop who wished to follow the ascetical life but could never extricate himself from civic and ecclesiastical responsibility. His Oration 14 rises from, and represents, his wider consideration of wealth as part of the divine economy of salvation. In his mind the only proper approach to the possession of wealth is one that accepts its extreme conditionality. No one can claim an absolute right to property since all humanity is given everything by the providence of a generous God. All things, the possession of life itself, but especially  material goods, can only be held in temporary stewardship by human beings.[2] Continue reading

Gregory of Nazianzus on Speech as the Foundation for Culture

In an interesting passage Gregory considers Julian’s Edict on the Professors, which forbade Christians to teach rhetoric. He considers the relationship between words or discourses (logoi) and the Word of God (Logos). Here again in this passage the essential relation between culture and religion is provided, for Gregory, by philanthropy. Here he argues that discourse (human logos), which covers all aspects of societal association, from basic communications to the heights of gracious rhetoric, is the root and foundation of all civilized society. This bonding of mankind by means discourse, gives to the latter its religious quality:

Human speech does not belong to those who invented it,[1] rather is it the possession of all who participate in it, or any other art. The Creative Word, the Demiurge, gave to various people the gift of discovering or instituting a variety of arts, but he sets each one of the arts in the midst of all, for whoever wanted to make use of them, that they should form a common bond of philanthropy, to make our human lot so much better.[2]

John McGuckin, Gregory of Nazianzus: An Intellectual Biography (SVS Press: Crestwood, 2001), 123.


[1]  Answering Julian’s claim that Greek letters belonged, inalienably to the Hellenes, not the Christians.

[2] Orat. 4.106, PG 35.641.

Analysis of Basil’s Argument – Contemporary Application, Conclusion, and Bibliography

Contemporary Application

On the Holy Spirit is a treatise that will continue to have significance for future Christian generations. Two issues stand out specifically. The first is the way theology relates to Christian worship. The outward forms of Christianity may differ from culture to culture, but that does not make them relative or meaningless. Basil’s use of the with doxology reflects the growth of theological understanding into practice. There is, or at least should be, a strong theological understanding for the way Churches conduct themselves—not just personal opinion. The reason for this is that the very practices of a church will do just as much to influence theological understanding as will Scriptural exegesis—lex orandi, lex credendi. Christianity is not an ethereal religion; it is a religion that encompasses the entirety of life—physical and spiritual. It would behoove modern and future Christian generations to pay careful attention to the practices of their church in order to safeguard a right understanding of who God is and what God does. Continue reading

Mark DelCogliano’s Dissertation Online

Found out today that you can download Mark DelCogliano’s dissertation, Basil of Caesarea’s Anti-Eunomian Theory of Names, online for free instead of the $120 or so book published by Brill: http://pid.emory.edu/ark:/25593/1cch0 (or, if you don’t want to bother going all the way over to Emory’s site, download directly from this link: https://etd.library.emory.edu/file/view/pid/emory:1ccj4/delcogliano_dissertation.pdf)

Analysis of Basil’s Argument – Issues Not Addressed

Issue not Addressed

When reading this treatise, one it struck by the amount of detail that Basil goes through to make his point. This is important and indeed vital to what he is trying to argue. Ironically, his attempt to argue for the validity of a Church practice lacks practicality. While the divinity of the Holy Spirit makes his congregation feel that they have avoided idolatry, what else does it do? How does the divinity of the Holy Spirit affect the average person’s piety outside of the congregational worship? Continue reading